Most weak validation packages trace back to a weak user requirements specification (URS): a document that describes a wish list, not testable requirements tied to the intended use of the system.
Start from intended use
A URS exists to state what the system must do for the regulated process it supports. Good practice, reflected in EU GMP Annex 11 and in GAMP guidance, is to define intended use first, then derive requirements and the validation effort from the risk of that use. A requirement that cannot be traced to a process need, a regulatory expectation or a patient or product risk probably should not be there.
Qualities of a good requirement
- Unambiguous: one meaning, no phrases such as “user-friendly” or “fast”.
- Testable: you can describe what a pass looks like before the system is built.
- Uniquely identified: numbered so it can be traced to specifications and tests.
- Prioritised: mandatory requirements separated from desirable ones, which supports supplier selection.
Requirement categories to cover
- Functional requirements for the regulated process.
- Data integrity needs: audit trail, access control, electronic records and signatures where used.
- Interfaces with other systems and data migration.
- Security, backup, recovery and business continuity.
- Reporting, retention and archiving.
- Regulatory and quality system constraints, including supplier and support expectations.
Common mistakes
- Copying the supplier’s brochure into the URS and calling it requirements.
- Writing the URS after the system has been selected, so it simply describes the product.
- Mixing requirements with design solutions.
- Leaving the URS unchanged while the process evolves, which breaks traceability.
Connecting the URS to the rest of validation
The URS is the anchor for the traceability matrix, the risk assessment and the test strategy. A risk-based approach lets low-risk requirements rely on supplier testing while concentrating effort on the functions that affect data integrity, product quality or patient safety. The URS should be reviewed and approved by the process owner, with quality assurance involved, and kept under change control.
Related reading
- Computerised System Validation: A Risk-Based Lifecycle That Survives Inspection
- GAMP 5 Software Categories: Matching Validation Effort to What You Bought
- Computer Software Assurance: What FDA’s Final CSA Guidance Changes
How PQRA helps
PQRA helps process owners draft and review URS documents, build traceability into the validation plan, and scale validation effort to risk so that the package is proportionate and defensible at inspection.
Ready to talk it through? Contact the PQRA team.


No responses yet