Qualification is the evidence that equipment and facilities are fit for their intended use. Done well, it starts with a clear requirement, not with an installation protocol.
The Annex 15 stages
Annex 15 sets out a staged approach. Each stage builds on the previous one, and the scope is risk-based.
- User requirements specification (URS): defines what the equipment or system must do and serves as the reference throughout its lifecycle.
- Design qualification (DQ): documented verification that the proposed design meets GMP requirements and the URS.
- FAT and SAT: factory and site acceptance testing. Annex 15 allows documentation review and some tests at the vendor’s site to avoid repetition on site, provided this is justified.
- Installation qualification (IQ): verifies correct installation, calibration, supplier documents and materials of construction.
- Operational qualification (OQ): verifies operation across the intended range, including upper and lower operating limits and worst-case conditions.
- Performance qualification (PQ): demonstrates performance under normal conditions using production materials or proven substitutes, including worst-case batch sizes where relevant.
Common weaknesses
- A URS written after purchase to match what was bought, so it can never reveal a mismatch.
- OQ tests run only at nominal settings, without challenging the limits the process will actually use.
- Protocols executed with unexplained deviations or acceptance criteria changed during execution.
- Vendor documents accepted without a documented assessment of their adequacy.
Staying qualified
Annex 15 expects equipment and systems to be re-evaluated at a justified frequency and notes that the possibility of small changes over time should be assessed. Preventive maintenance, calibration, change control and periodic review all contribute. Annex 15 also states that planned changes likely to affect product quality should be formally controlled, with their impact on the qualified state assessed.
Linking qualification to the rest of the system
Qualification supports process validation and cleaning validation, and the analytical methods used in qualification should themselves be validated. For computerised systems, Annex 11 and a lifecycle approach apply alongside Annex 15. Keep a validation master plan or equivalent so that the overall status of facilities, utilities and equipment is visible at a glance.
A short self-check
- Can each URS requirement be traced to a test in the qualification package?
- Were acceptance criteria fixed before execution began?
- Is there a defined requalification or periodic review frequency, with a rationale?
How PQRA helps
PQRA helps manufacturers write URS documents, qualification protocols and reports, assess vendor documentation, and review existing qualification packages for gaps against Annex 15. We can also support the validation master plan and the periodic review process that keeps equipment in a qualified state.
Contact PQRA to discuss how we can support your quality system.


No responses yet