On-Hold Botanical Health Claims: Why They Remain a Compliance Risk

For well over a decade, claims for botanical ingredients have sat in an unresolved state under the EU nutrition and health claims rules. Using them is tolerated in some markets but carries real legal and commercial risk.

What on hold means

When the Article 13 list of permitted health claims was adopted, a large group of claims for botanical substances was left undecided pending further assessment. Reporting from 2024 puts the number at around 2,000 claims, on hold since 2012, held on EFSA on-hold register rather than authorised or rejected. Companies have been able to use them under transitional measures, if the claim and the product conform to the conditions.

Why pressure is growing

A European Parliament implementation report on the Regulation, reported in early 2024, flagged legal concerns about the continued use of on-hold claims and the risk of misleading consumers. A related Parliament resolution called on the Commission to reject on-hold claims that have been assessed negatively, to coordinate with Member States on botanical supplements, and to consider an EU-level negative list of botanicals with guidance. No final decision was reported in that coverage, so the current position should be checked.

Practical risks

  • Enforcement differs by Member State, so a claim tolerated in one country may be challenged in another.
  • Claims may be withdrawn or rejected with limited notice, forcing rapid relabelling.
  • Competitors, authorities or consumer bodies may challenge claims.
  • Retailers and marketplaces may apply stricter rules than the law.

A sensible approach

Keep a register of every botanical claim you use, with its status and evidence. Prefer wording that reflects traditional use or general wellbeing only where permitted, avoid disease claims, and have a plan to change labelling quickly. Consider separate regulatory routes, such as traditional herbal medicinal product registration, where a therapeutic claim is central to the product.

How PQRA helps

PQRA helps supplement companies review claims against the register, assess whether a product should be positioned as a food or a medicine, and prepare compliant labelling and marketing for Greece and the EU.

Using botanical claims on your labels? Contact PQRA for a practical discussion.

CATEGORIES:

Uncategorized

Tags:

No responses yet

Αφήστε μια απάντηση

Η ηλ. διεύθυνση σας δεν δημοσιεύεται. Τα υποχρεωτικά πεδία σημειώνονται με *