Validating an MES and Electronic Batch Records: Where Process Control Meets Data Integrity

A manufacturing execution system replaces the paper batch record with enforced steps, electronic checks and signatures. That makes it a GMP record, a process control and an integration project at once, and validation has to cover all three.

Treat master data as part of the validated system

In an electronic batch record, the master batch record is data held in the system: recipe steps, limits, bills of materials and instructions. A programming error here is a batch record error repeated on every batch. Define how master data is authored, reviewed, approved and versioned, and test that the version an operator sees is the version that was approved.

Challenge the enforcement logic

The benefit of an MES is that it can stop an operator from proceeding when something is wrong. Your testing should prove that it does. Useful scenarios include:

  • Entry of out-of-range values, missing entries and wrong-material scans
  • Sequence enforcement, bypass attempts and handling of deviations raised during execution
  • Calculated fields, yield reconciliation and in-process control results
  • Review by exception: confirmation that the exception report really captures every flagged event
  • Electronic signatures, linked to the record, with meaning and date shown, as Annex 11 requires

Do not forget interfaces and downtime

An MES rarely works alone. Check the interfaces to ERP, weighing and dispensing systems, equipment and the laboratory, and confirm what happens when one of them is unavailable. Business continuity arrangements, including how production continues and how records are reconciled afterwards, should be documented and tested, not assumed.

Release decisions rely on the record

The qualified person certifies batches on the basis of records the MES generates. Make sure the batch record review process is defined for the electronic format, that printed or exported copies are complete and accurate, and that the record remains readable for as long as the retention period requires.

Common weaknesses worth checking now

Typical weaknesses include a requirements specification that was written after the system was chosen, test scripts that only confirm the happy path, and a configuration that has drifted from the approved baseline through undocumented changes. A short internal review against each of these, using a sample of recent changes, will show quickly whether the validated state is real. Record the outcome and any follow-up, and bring it to the next quality review so that the findings reach those who decide on resources.

How PQRA helps

PQRA can help you define user requirements for an MES or electronic batch record project, plan a risk-based validation approach, review the testing of enforcement logic and interfaces, and prepare the documentation that supports qualified person release and inspection readiness.

Contact PQRA to discuss your computerised systems and data governance programme.

CATEGORIES:

Uncategorized

Tags:

No responses yet

Αφήστε μια απάντηση

Η ηλ. διεύθυνση σας δεν δημοσιεύεται. Τα υποχρεωτικά πεδία σημειώνονται με *